Compare Quotes in 2 Minutes
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
What is a car insurance deductible and how does it work? Simply put, a deductible is the amount you pay out-of-pocket when making a claim before your insurance coverage kicks in. Insurance deductibles allow drivers to reduce their monthly premiums by agreeing to cover some initial claim costs if an accident or incident occurs. The best car insurance deductible will vary driver by driver so it’s really subjective.
Insurance companies typically offer deductible options ranging from $0 up to $2,500 or more. The higher your chosen deductible amount, the lower your auto policy payments will be on a monthly basis. However, you take on greater financial risk for potential out-of-pocket expenditures when damage or collisions happen.
It’s crucial to find the right balance based on your personal budget, income level, assets, risk tolerance, and more. Below we’ll explore popular and good car insurance deductible options, their pros and cons, the claims process, and provide sample quotes at different amounts.
$0 Deductible Car Insurance
Some specialized auto insurance policies are available with $0 deductibles, meaning the insurer covers 100% of all approved claim costs without requiring the policyholder to pay anything themselves. While premiums will be more expensive, this option eliminates almost all financial risks if you need to file claims.
|Pros of $0 Deductible
|Cons of $0 Deductible
|You pay absolutely nothing on covered claims; very convenient!
|Much pricier monthly premiums, often excessively high.
|Great for risk-averse drivers wanting maximum financial protection.
|Typically only offered for top-tier, max coverage insurance plans.
|Can potentially be bundled with other home/life policies for multi-policy discounts.
|Frequent claims could negatively impact renewal pricing down the road.
The Claims Process with No Deductible
If you choose a $0 deductible, the claims process is straightforward. You bring your insured vehicle to an approved repair shop or have it towed there if badly damaged. Repairs up to the coverage limits and exclusions on your policy are covered in full once the claim is approved. All you provide is some basic documentation and information.
The shop handles direct billing to the insurance company. You may need to provide authorization for certain repairs or parts as they assess the vehicle. But otherwise, you can get your car fixed with zero out-of-pocket costs beyond the higher premiums already paid. Very convenient!
$250 Car Insurance Deductible
A $250 deductible sits on the low end of options but comes with barely any upfront out-of-pocket costs relative to potential claim amounts. This deductible nicely fits lower-income households wanting to minimize financial risks yet keep cheaper payments.
|Pros of $250 Deductible
|Cons of $250 Deductible
|Very affordable amount for most families budget-wise.
|Can still be a burden for extremely tight budgets.
|Allows peace of mind when deciding to file smaller claims.
|Potential for moderate premium hikes after multiple claims.
|Usually 20-30% cheaper monthly premiums than $0 options.
|Less available from high-end ‘premier’ insurance companies.
$250 Deductible Claims Process
The claims process works very similarly to the $0 deductible option above. But in this case, you first pay your chosen $250 amount after claim approval directly to the repair shop or by reimbursement. The insurance company then covers all remaining valid repair and parts costs.
So you have some reasonable skin in the game financially, but costs beyond the deductible are fully covered by insurance with no headaches. Just be sure to have $250 readily available in case an accident happens!
$500 Car Insurance Deductible
Many people think the best car insurance deductible is $500. It’s a very popular middle ground choice for many drivers and it balances out-of-pocket costs versus cheaper monthly savings. Many average households find this amount very reasonable to pay if and when accidents occur before insurance kicks in.
|Pros of $500 Deductible
|Cons of $500 Deductible
|Widely available from almost every major auto insurer.
|Potentially still a substantial financial burden for lower-income drivers.
|Considered an affordable amount by most middle-class families.
|Needs some savings set aside in case accident repairs are required.
|Saves roughly 30% off premium costs versus $250 deductible policies.
|Claims made can negatively impact your renewal premiums.
$500 Deductible Claims Experience
After approval by both you and the insurer, the repair facility charges your provided $500 deductible amount upfront before additional repair work is performed. Some insurers may offer flexibility by reimbursing you the $500 later on after fixes are complete.
But generally expect to pay the deductible directly at the time of repairs either way. The shop then bills all remaining costs past $500 to your insurance provider subject to coverage limits and exclusions. Fairly straightforward!
$1,000 Deductible Car Insurance
For drivers focused heavily on minimizing their monthly payments even if it means taking on more potential financial risk, a $1,000 deductible is a popular option. However, the higher out-of-pocket costs must be carefully weighed if filing any claims.
|Pros of $1,000 Deductible
|Cons of $1,000 Deductible
|Substantially cheaper monthly premiums; excellent budget saver.
|A $1,000 repair bill can be daunting for many households if accidents happen!
|Nearly universally available from top national auto insurers.
|Legitimate claims under $1,000 may not get filed due to high deductions.
|1 in 4 drivers choose this amount nationally based on surveys.
|Increases delays getting the vehicle fixed; need cash reserves available.
$1,000 Deductible Claims Process & Considerations
The claims process functions the same way as described for lower deductibles above. But coming up with $1,000 out-of-pocket on short notice poses much more of a challenge for policyholders – especially lower and middle-income families living paycheck to paycheck.
Also, the high upfront cost makes submitting sub $1,000 claims illogical financially even if repairs are truly needed. Filing claims can also drive up your premiums at renewal time. For $1,000 deductibles, have at least that amount set aside for sudden accidents, or consider lowering your amount.
Some Drivers Opt For a $2,000 Car Insurance Deductible
On the highest end of typical ranges, drivers focused extremely heavily on lowering monthly costs may opt for a $2,000 deductible – especially if maintaining a robust emergency savings fund as a buffer for out-of-pocket claim expenses.
|Pros of $2,000 Deductible
|Cons of $2,000 Deductible
|Drastically cheaper monthly auto insurance premiums
|Difficult for average-income families to cover $2,000 repair bills
|Money saved on premiums can more easily cover $2,000 costs if needed
|Many legitimate sub-$2,000 claims likely won’t get filed
|A good option for high-net-worth households of all assets are protected elsewhere
|Severely limits repair options if cash reserves are too low
$2,000 Deductible Claims Process
A $2,000 deductible works similarly to lower amounts at the time of claim filing – you pay costs up to $2,000 before insurance kicks in. But have ample savings set aside! Even minor fender benders or cracked windshields come mostly out of your pocket – likely making small claims not worth the effort.
While maxing deductibles to $2,000 provides the absolute lowest premiums, assess coverage tradeoffs and exclusions as well. Some insurers reduce additional benefits above state minimums if you pick excessively high deductibles. Make sure a $2,000 amount aligns with your overall financial situation first!
Comparing Car Insurance Quotes at Different Deductibles
To demonstrate exactly how picking lower versus much higher deductibles impacts your auto policy’s total premium costs, check out these sample auto insurance quotes from major national car insurance providers. Sample rates include a 35-year-old male driving a 2014 Toyota Corolla.
|Geico Car Insurance
|Allstate Auto Insurance
|State Farm Car Insurance
|$220 per month
|$255 per month
|$156 per month
|$201 per month
|$178 per month
|$137 per month
|$169 per month
|$155 per month
|$118 per month
|$143 per month
|$133 per month
As shown, a Geico policyholder could save over $100 monthly by raising deductibles to just $750 higher. That’s $1,200+ in savings over an entire policy term!
While Allstate doesn’t offer a maximum of $0 deductibles, buyers can still get over $55 off monthly payments with a $1000 amount versus the lowest $250 option.
State Farm actually features a rare $0 deductible policy at $255 monthly, while a $1000 deductible drops costs over $120 lower.
The Cost Savings of Raising Your Deductible
Based on the rate comparison above, deductions in the $500 to $1000 range compared to low $250 or none save drivers anywhere from $500 all the way up to $1,500+ per year on premium costs!
Shopping around for deductible options makes a massive difference in what you ultimately pay for equivalent auto insurance coverage. Just make sure to have money set aside should an accident occur with higher deductibles selected.
Analyze Coverage Gaps Too
Also, pay attention to any change in coverage restrictions or exclusions at different deductibles. Some insurers reduce accident forgiveness benefits or include sub-limits on certain repairs if you pick higher vs lower deductibles. So read all policy documentation carefully before deciding.
Maximize overall coverage while balancing out-of-pocket risks and premium costs. And utilize all available discounts like bundling home/auto, defensive driving courses, and more! Carefully weighing deductibles takes time but earns huge medium to long-term savings.
The Final Word On The Best Car Insurance Deductible
Whether you currently have auto insurance or will be purchasing a new policy soon, one of the most impactful decisions is choosing a good car insurance deductible amount. Car insurance deductibles represent the out-of-pocket costs you’re responsible for paying when collision repairs or accident claims are necessary before the insurance company covers the remaining fees.
Evaluate tradeoffs between premium costs, out-of-pocket risks, available savings, and more when deciding on a recommended deductible for car insurance. And shop quotes around between leading insurers using the same deductible amounts for the fairest comparisons. Investing time upfront analyzing deductible options saves huge money over the long run. Now it’s time to compare quotes for the coverage and deductible you want. To get started enter your zip code and fill out a five-minute application. Save more money with direct auto insurance rates.